It was a visual treat for anyone who watched it and definitely a huge blockbuster making over 850 million USD in the box office despite the 27% critic rating at rotten tomatoes. The main reason for making the movie was to set up a universe and introduce new members for a future justice league film. Unfortunately the film didn't focus much on the title as much as it did about the second part, the Dawn of justice. There was a brief introduction to all the justice league members including cyborg aquaman and the flash. There were some good moments but the film overall failed to meet the expectations of the majority of people who watched it. It seemed like the film targeted only DC fans and they (myself included) welcomed it spectacularly. To this date, despite the controversies that arose, DC fans have stood by defending their heroes and their universe in spite of what the critics and normal audience say. That being said lets get back to the movie.
The movie faced too many problems ever since the release but personally, as a DC fan I enjoyed it very much and expect more from the upcoming movies. It definitely doesn't deserve razzie nominations but then again the razzies aren't taken too seriously. I loved Ben's new take on batman and loved the breathtaking visuals. But the only way to make both fans and critics happy is by sticking to the source material, not just the storyline, but the costumes, make-up and character. It would definitely be foolish to try out anything new or take any more risks especially this early. DC could definitely be a tough contender for Marvel if they keep that in mind and not try to rush things.
Verdict:
Theatrical version
Fan in me : 8/10
Critic in me : 7/10
Extended cut
Fan in me : 8.5/10 for the extra Clark Kent scenes
Critic in me: 7.5/10 story makes more sense
Posting this review on 25th March on account of the 1st year anniversary of the movie and before the official justice league trailer, fingers crossed expecting a great trailer and an even better movie, go DC!